Making Other People Happy Is Ruining Your Life

Keep scrolling down if you want to read the full post, otherwise you can watch the video version (above), or listen on your favourite podcast channel here:

Soundcloud:

Spotify:

Apple Podcasts:


Making Other People Happy Is Ruining Your Life

Most people pleasers believe that they’re kind and generous, that they care about others, but what if I was to tell you that most of what you’re doing is actually coming from a place of fear.

People pleasing isn’t about helping others, or making other people happy. It’s about controlling how you’re perceived so that you can avoid conflict, rejection, and being judged, and the cost of this particular strategy is enormous. You resent everybody, you lose track of who you are, and you create a life that’s ultimately quite miserable and uncomfortable.

So in this post, we’re going to cover the core lie behind people pleasing: the idea that you are making other people happy. We’re going to attack this lie so that we can rescue you from the trap that it’s put you in and help steer you towards a life you’ll actually enjoy and other people will even appreciate more. I’m not going to tell you to stop caring about other people. I’m going to show you why trying to make them happy doesn’t work, and why making people happy doesn’t mean that you’re a good person.

People pleasers aren’t bad, selfish or manipulative on purpose. There’s no conscious kind of manipulative drive here. In fact, if that was you, then you’re not really a people pleaser. If you know that you’re just using this to control people and you don’t actually care about them, then you’re more on the psychopathic or narcissistic spectrum. This post is for people who actually think of themselves as good people and think that making others happy is a good thing to be doing.

Most of the people I’ve ever worked with genuinely want to be kind to others. They want other people to have a good life. They want harmony in their social environment. They feel that what they’re doing is a strategy to improve people’s lives. That is their genuine motive underneath it all.

But over time, an awareness starts to build, a kind of paradox where you realize that what you’re doing feels moral, feels like the right thing to do, feels like you’re a good person, but then also something feels off about it. This is not just a feeling, but it’s apparent in the results in your life. You’re not getting the kind of karma that a good person should get. You’re not being rewarded for pleasing everybody. In fact, you’re just getting more and more miserable and exhausted and disconnected from who you really are. It seems like an odd result for somebody who’s been so good all the time.

So that’s the first thing I want you to notice, is people pleasing feels good – trying to make other people happy seems like a good thing to do – but in the long run, it does not produce good results. People are not getting healthier, your relationships are not getting better, you’re not loving yourself more as time goes on, and even the people you do this with don’t seem to be improving their lives as a result of it. So something is off.

We have to differentiate: people pleasing and being kind are not the same thing. Making other people happy and improving other people’s lives are not the same thing. I want you to start extricating those two ideas from each other. Kindness and pleasing people, they’re not the same.

What People Pleasing Actually Is

So if people pleasing isn’t kindness, then what is it? In essence, it’s prioritizing emotional comfort – theirs, which gives you yours – over being truthful.

The real key difference between people pleasing and true, genuine, confident kindness is honesty. People pleasers will sacrifice honesty to make somebody else happy, whereas a genuinely kind person will use honesty to improve other people’s lives – short-term happiness is not so much a consideration.

You’ve got to understand that you sacrificing yourself, pleasing others, and trying to make them happy is not you doing some sort of moral good. You’re not coming from a place of integrity and kindness. You’re coming from fear. This is a strategy to prevent certain outcomes that you’re uncomfortable with.

What is it that usually gets hidden when you’re a people pleaser? Your true opinions. That’s one of the first things to go. First off, you start to lie to others about your true opinions. Anytime you think you have a perspective on things that would upset other people or make them upset with you in some way, you will muddy or merge or outright lie about those. But after a while, you don’t even feel like you’re lying anymore, because you lie to yourself first. You start to change your opinion when you perceive (or even anticipate) that somebody else is going to have a bad reaction to it.

You might start with your original position, and then either because you can read the person, or you know them well, or they give you a signal, you realize they’re not going to react well to that position, you’ll actually argue yourself inside your head into the other position. You will change your opinion into one that’s going to get a better reaction. People pleasers often pride themselves on being easy going and seeing both sides of the story. What they really are is flexible with their opinions. They will move to meet you where you are. They will see your point of view as a way of making you like them, not because they actually agree with your point of view, but because they talk themselves into agreeing with it so they can avoid conflict.

One of the main types of opinions they hide are their preferences: what they want / don’t want, like /  dislike. I’ve talked about this in so much of my content. Who you are is made up of your preferences, and that’s one of the first things to go when you want to please other people, because if you are to be completely honest about every preference you have, you’re going to upset people. It’s only a matter of time. Even the people who love you the most – at least one percent of your preferences will upset them. So in order for you to not upset anyone, you have to start sacrificing your preferences.

You can’t even say them out loud let alone act upon them. When I say you sacrifice them, I mean they don’t even get expressed. I don’t mean that you express them and then take the loss. That’s actually quite honest. No, you don’t even show them in the first place. You pretend they don’t exist.

And because your opinions and your preferences are being suppressed, boundaries are the next to go. How is it that you’re supposed to set boundaries with someone, tell them what it means to respect you and so on, if you’re not even telling them what you like and what you don’t like and what you believe in?

You’ve become so flexible about who you are (depending on who you’re with) that there are no boundaries to set. It feels like you don’t need to. It feels quite genuinely like you’ve got no problem with anyone. The truth is, you’ve turned yourself into someone that nobody can have a problem with, because you will just fold whenever they push. You don’t have any boundaries. It’s like your property doesn’t have a fence line – people can just walk right across it, and you tell yourself that this means that you’re easy going and you get along well with people and it’s nice to be around you, because you don’t cause problems.

In truth, you’ve just turned yourself into a ghost that fits any container. You don’t have any solid form. You don’t have a personality. You don’t have preferences. You don’t have deal breakers that you hold strong with people. That doesn’t make you a good person. It makes you dishonest.

And of course, now that your boundaries have been sacrificed, you’re going to be disappointed with people, because even when you’ve talked yourself into believing that you’re fine with everything, deep down you know you’re not. Now this might not quite arise into your conscious awareness, but you will be upset with other people’s behavior. You will secretly resent them. You’ll have covert contracts with them where you expected them to be one way and they didn’t do it, but you don’t want to confront them, so you just sit there sulking on the inside, hoping that somehow they’ll notice and correct their behavior. Or you won’t even do that, because you believe that whatever you want is not even worth expressing; that everybody else is right and you’re always wrong, but you’ll still be upset with what they did. There’s still things you wish people did differently. There’s still preferences you have for their behavior. So you can’t help but feel disappointed in them, frustrated with them, and after a while, quite full of rage.

One of the main things that you hide are your desires, particularly anything that’s high stakes, like sexual attraction, or something that would be competitive with others, or something that’s really outside of the norm. You don’t honor the things that you want, the things that you yearn for. It’s another type of preference, but particularly a preference for things that would make your life thrive, that would make your heart sing. You squash all of these because usually feeling that strongly about anything is just too risky. It feels like it’s going to provoke a confrontation or discouragement or judgment from others.

And so you dishonor yourself, you disrespect yourself in this way, and then you tell yourself you’re a good person for doing this, even though you have a double standard where you let other people do what they want. If other people want to express their desires, no problem. If other people say they’re disappointed, you’ll jump on it and fix it. But you? No way. You’ve got a different set of rules you’ve got to live by.

The Four Fears Behind People Pleasing

Why don’t you express all this stuff? If you’re such a good person, why aren’t you honest about all these basic things that don’t really harm anyone in any major way?

You’re not trying to enhance anyone else’s life. There’s four main horsemen that you’re avoiding here.

The first, of course, is rejection. You hide these things because you think that if somebody else disagrees with you, that’s the same as them completely disliking you, which means they will reject you. You’ve convinced yourself long ago that this is a bad thing. It must be avoided. You’re so sure that another person not liking you and disagreeing with you is some sort of harmful event that must be prevented, like you wouldn’t survive it, or like it would spread and everybody else would ostracize you.

Second one, of course, is conflict: confrontation, arguments, any sort of heated emotional exchange. This one isn’t so much just about being disliked, but about being with a person while they feel very uncomfortable things about you, and you feel uncomfortable things in reaction to them feeling that way. It could be a fear of violence as well. But mostly it’s just about a fear of somebody being upset with you, being angry with you, being disappointed in you, being confused by what you said; having any sort of disagreeable, disgusted, distasteful feeling about you. It’s not even the content that bothers you. It’s just the feelings. If anyone feels that way about you, you take that as a huge threat, not just because of  potential rejections that might come from it, but from the actual moment of being there. It’s so unbearable for you that you do anything to prevent it.

Guilt is the third one, or shame is maybe a better word. The reason you people-please and hide your preferences is because at some point, a long time ago, you decided there was something wrong with you. Other people can have their preferences, other people can get their way, but you’re not allowed to. It’s a double standard because there’s something broken about you, wrong about you, and so whenever you upset somebody else, your first thought is, “Oh, that’s my wrongness hurting other people.” We don’t think, “Hey, maybe they’re a bit too sensitive, or maybe they just have to handle life better.” We think, “No, I’ve done something wrong because I’m a bad person.”

Ultimately, all the striving you’re doing to be seen as a good person, to try and convince others and yourself that you’re a good person, it’s because deep down you’re convinced that you’re not one, and that you need to somehow overcorrect to make up for that.

The fourth one is disapproval, this idea that somebody else has decided that you’re a bad person, that there’s something wrong with you. Disapproval is evidence that it’s true. We consider disapproval to be a problem that needs to be solved, to be something that is unquestionably true. So if someone disapproves of me and thinks there’s something wrong with me and thinks I’m wrong, we don’t even doubt that they might be incorrect in their assessment, that they might be working with the wrong information, that their opinion might not fucking matter. We just go, “Oh, there’s that proof. Oh no!” And we do everything we can to prevent disapproval happening, to try and keep people floating along thinking that we’re a good person and never finding out that we’re not.

This idea that you’re trying to make people happy? No. You take their happiness as a sign that you’re preventing conflict, preventing disapproval, and so on. It’s not really that you want them to be happy. It’s that you don’t want them to be upset with you because that is upsetting for you. That’s all this is. This isn’t about their happiness. Happiness is just the one state that you can handle them being in. People pleasing is for your benefit, not theirs.

Put it this way. If a people pleaser had a choice: make someone happy or upset them, and yet they knew that upsetting them was best for their quality of life, they’d still choose making them happy, because it’s really about you and what you want, not really what’s best for the other person.

And how do we know this is true? Because the truth is what’s best for the other person – the best possible data for them to make decisions, the full picture, the feedback they need, and yet you constantly deprive them of that because you know they’ll be upset with it. Their short-term, disagreeable reaction to the truth is not worth it for you, even though it improves their quality of life in the long run. Like giving someone hurtful feedback, it helps them improve their behavior, but you’d rather keep them happy here and now, even though it means depriving them of the information they need, the truth to make the best decisions with their life.

So please, if nothing else, by the end of this post, stop telling yourself you’re a good person for making others happy. That’s not why you’re doing it.

The Core Lie

This brings us to the core lie, which is,

If I keep other people happy, that makes me a good person.

This is the system that you’re working with, the fundamental core belief. Now how do we form such a belief? You might think it just makes sense. Yeah, if you make other people happy, you’re a good person. Totally makes sense. Have another look at it. Imagine that that doesn’t make sense to a lot of people; that you’re the only one who thinks this; you’re living in some sort of delusion that other people don’t agree with.

Why would somebody come to the belief that making other people happy – manipulating them into being happy – means that you’re a good, decent, moral person? In a nutshell, childhood conditioning. You were raised in such a way where making people happy caused you safety, right? Where controlling other people’s emotions and getting them to a happy state prevented bad things from happening to you. Maybe you had really strict parents and they got easily upset with you speaking your mind or doing what you wanted to do or taking risks. And then eventually you picked up on the idea that if you do exactly what it is that they want you to do and they’re happy, nothing bad happens to you. So that must mean you’re a good person, because you’re not being punished.

Maybe making the kids laugh at the playground stopped them from bullying you. You came to the conclusion like, “Okay, if I cause that sensation of happiness with a laugh, the bad things stop happening to me. So that’s what a good person does, because otherwise why would bad things happen to me if I was being good?”

I think that’s the fundamental problem that children being raised have, is they assume that if bad things happen to them, punishments, then they must be bad people receiving fair treatment. Children are very self-centered until about the age of nine or ten. The brain doesn’t develop the ability to realize things don’t make sense in that way – i.e. you can be a good person and still have bad things happen to you, you can do everything right and still lose, and other people doing bad things to you is not evidence of who you are as a person, it’s evidence of who they are. Kids don’t understand all that. The parent yells at them, the kid goes, “I did something wrong,” not, “Hey, this person doesn’t know how to control their fucking anger. It’s fine.” They don’t do that. They don’t have that kind of critical thinking.

And another thing that happens to a lot of nice guys, like myself, is we get praised for compliance. So we don’t just get the removal of bad things for being easy to deal with and making people happy, but we get rewarded for making people happy as well. It could be just you only get attention when you’re making people laugh. That was a big one for me. I only got attention if I was doing well in school or performing in some way, like playing guitar really well or being really funny. Other than that, I’d get ignored, which I felt like was a punishment. So I constantly got rewarded for being compliant and making people happy, so I started thinking, “Well, I must be on track. That must be the way I need to go. I like these rewards. I like the sensations I get when everyone thinks I’m the funniest guy in the room or they go, oh my God, you’re getting so good at guitar now. Must be on track. These are my milestones, my guideposts.”

Sometimes some of the people pleasers I work with haven’t had anything really that traumatically bad happen to them in childhood. You know, they had decent enough parents, weren’t too rough or strict or anything. They weren’t bullied at school. They had a lot of friends. But they got so rewarded for making people happy that it just overrode their moral system. They became obsessed with chasing that high. Always being the best in the class, always being the coolest kid, the best at sports, whatever it was that they got their rewards from. And so they became “good person” approval/validation-seeking addicts.

In particular, the kind of punishment we get as kids is for being emotionally inconvenient. That’s one of the most brutal things. If you watch most parents now, they will say No to their kid, tell them off, punish them, not because the kid’s actually done anything harmful, but just because the emotions required to deal with the kid are a hassle. Now, if a kid’s running around screaming and stuff, that’s not actually harmful. It’s not like they’re stabbing people, right? They’re not embezzling money. It’s running around making a lot of noise. But if you are tired and sleep deprived and sensitive to noise, you’ll say, “Stop that!” as if they’re doing something wrong.

Now the kid doesn’t understand that you’re just sensitive to noise. They just think they’re a bad person. They go, “Okay, if I cause grumpiness, I’m a bad person.” They start to get conditioned and programmed into thinking that being an inconvenience emotionally for someone who can’t handle their shit means that you need to change. They just don’t have the kind of maturity needed to go, “Wait, if you don’t like noise then you shouldn’t have had kids, motherfucker. Piss off!” They can’t think like that. They just go, “Oh no, I’m bad!”

And most parents don’t sit down and go, “Wait, that was actually my bad. That’s fine if you shout. Nothing bad really happened.” Or, “You drew that artwork and while it’s not my favourite, you like it, so that’s good enough.” Parents don’t talk to their kids this way often enough, so kids have to figure it out on their own. And let’s face it, kids are kinda stupid.

It’s not long before it becomes subconscious programming. For most of you, it became unconscious early in childhood. By the time you got to high school, you’re already programmed. Some of you might have been a bit more conscious than that, but generally it just feels really automatic. You don’t even think through the way you respond.

You’re hyper-vigilant. As soon as you start seeing disagreement form or you predict that it might happen, you automatically change course. You don’t actually wait for bad things to happen. You predict them and avoid them, prevent them. You start to feel like this is a mature, intelligent way to respond. You look at other people getting all upset and getting emotional, and you look down on them. You feel superior to them. You say, “Ah, they don’t know how to be easy going. They can’t handle anything. They could learn a thing or two from me.”

I remember going through a big superiority phase in high school where I thought of everybody else as being a selfish jerk who just hurt other people to get what they wanted, and I was this advanced human being who could be easy-going about everything and take care of everybody else’s needs. I was the hero that came to save the day. The idea that I was the most psychologically fucked up never occurred to me. I thought it was the opposite. It was only once I got into my twenties where I was like, “I don’t seem to be functioning as well as everybody else. Maybe I’m missing something.”


Build your confidence and integrity in just a few hours!

>> Click here to claim your course!


Caring Is Not Managing Emotions

You must understand the distortion: caring about other people does not mean managing their emotions so that you feel better. I mean, that should be obvious once you hear it out loud. Once you see yourself doing it in practice, it’s much more subtle, because they often do seem to feel better. They might even thank you for it like, “Oh, thank you for cheering me up.” So you’re thinking like, “I’m getting nothing but green lights here. I’m doing well!”

Maybe they shouldn’t have been cheered up! Maybe they should have finished their grieving process. Maybe you shouldn’t have ‘helped’ them with that thing, and they should have figured it out on their own so that they can develop some skills. Just because they said thank you doesn’t mean you actually improved their long-term quality of life. They just feel good, and maybe they just want to be polite. We don’t even know why they’re saying thank you. You don’t even know why you’re getting praised.

You’re not responsible for the way they feel, and whoever conditioned you into believing that was unhealthy and wrong for programming you in that way. If your parents trained you to manage their emotions for them, your parents are fucked up, and that’s no longer your burden.

You’ve grown up and now you’re terrified of being honest about so many different things. You lie and prevaricate and exaggerate and hide various truths all the time, constantly justifying this to yourself as “I’m making others happy, therefore it’s good to do it.” But when’s the last time you actually sat down and thought, what am I afraid of?

There’s this thing I call around-the-corner fear, which is when you’re afraid of something, but you don’t know exactly what it is. Your brain convinces you that this thing is definitely scary, and you don’t need to know anything more about it. There’s something around the corner making a big scary noise, and your brain goes, “That’s a terrible monster, trust me, don’t even look at the thing. Just don’t go around the corner.”

When people are afraid of honesty, they often have some vague reasons. I’ll get rejected or people won’t like me, but they haven’t actually thought through what they are even saying and why that would be something to be scared of. Like if you were to tell me, “I’m afraid of rejection,” and I said, “Why?” – what’s your answer to that? What is it about rejection that’s so harmful? What is that big scary thing around the corner? I’ve been rejected literally thousands of times and don’t have a single scar or any emotional trauma from it.

So you go up to someone, and they say, “I don’t like you”… then what happens? Fucking nothing. You’re treating it as if they’re going to go, “I’m sorry, I don’t like you, and now I’m going to have to shoot you in the kneecaps and kidnap your family, because those are the rules.” You’re behaving as if something that bad is going to happen.

Of course, at this point I’ve asked thousands of coaching clients what it is they’re afraid of, and there’s some common answers that come up. The main one is something along the lines of, they’ll be upset. Now the word upset can be interchanged with unhappy or angry or sad or disappointed. There’s lots of versions of upset, sometimes a big range, and it depends on the person. But a lot of people will talk about that as if that’s objectively harmful, like, “They’d be upset. Case closed. We don’t need to explain any further why that’s something to avoid.”

Of course, with my own self-development and so on, I know to ask, “Why is them being upset something to be afraid of?” And that’s usually where they start stumbling. But then they’ll go into, “I’m going to be rejected,” as in people are going to leave me, abandon me. If a guy is worried about upsetting his wife, I  ask why? “Because she’ll divorce me. She’ll take the kids, and I’ll be all by myself for the rest of my life living in a ditch.”

You get these catastrophic stories where not only does the person leave you and abandon you, but somehow that does a lot of damage to you. Now I’m not saying that these are all delusional. In fact, it might exactly be what will happen – ironically, it’d be caused by the people pleasing in the first place. But generally, this idea that I will be left alone, it’s a very childlike thing to feel and worry about, isn’t it? I mean, an adult is actually fine on their own.

So when a full grown adult says, “But they’ll leave me,” there’s a childlike quality to it. It’s fine if they leave you. Why are you worried about that? If you’re a six-year-old, somebody leaving you is a big deal. If you got no friends at school, it’s a horrible experience. If your parents turn their backs on you, you’re very unsafe. So this is an immature response. People will be upset and then leave me, and that is definitely bad, even though for an adult that’s not objectively true.

Then there’s this reputational risk that often comes up: they’ll think less of me, but not just that, this will spread around. So me disappointing someone, it’s not really just that – this person is going to somehow make other people aware of how disappointing I am. There’s this thing called reputation, this accumulated compound view of how everybody sees me, the kind of average opinion of me. And if I upset even one person, it’s like dropping a drip of poison into my reputation. It will spread throughout and suddenly everybody will think I’m a bad person and everybody will leave me.

It’s like that imposter syndrome. “I’ll be found out as a bad person and it’ll be too big to control. I won’t be able to fix it.”

You’ll notice that sometimes people pleasers are okay with upsetting someone when they feel that it can’t go anywhere. Ironically somebody will be a people pleaser at work, but when they get into the online comments anonymously, they transform into nasty trolls. They’re horrible to people. Or if they’re in a different country, they’re suddenly much bolder with what they say, and so on. Once a people pleaser believes that their reputation can’t possibly be tarnished, then the knives come out. Not always, but sometimes, which just gives you an indication as to what they really care about.

Even if we set aside what everybody else thinks of you, a people pleaser will feel like a bad person all on their own for upsetting someone else, and they can do this even when other people validate it. So even if other people say, “Look, you did the right thing, don’t worry about them being upset. They are the wrong person in this one.” They’ll still feel guilty just because somebody else was upset. We take that as hard evidence that we’re a bad person.

It doesn’t matter what anyone else says. We’re already whipping ourselves on the back for having failed so miserably, trying to think of a way that we could have done that without upsetting someone else. This is horrible for people pleasers, because people pleasing itself is upsetting for some people! So there’s just no way for a people pleaser to escape it. You’re always going to disappoint someone and upset someone. It’s inevitable, no matter how hard you try, because even trying hard is upsetting to some people. You’re constantly feeling guilty and beating yourself up, feeling like a bad person because you just can’t get it right perfectly.

People pleasing is not about caring for others. It’s about using dishonesty to control other people. That’s all this is, to avoid the outcomes that you’re so terrified of.

The Cost of People Pleasing

So what’s the problem with this? I mean, I’ve had a few people come to me saying, “Well, I just want to be a people pleaser forever.” Well, fair enough, you do what you want with your life. But do I agree that that’s actually a viable option? No. There is no way to maintain people pleasing without disaster at the end of the road. I firmly believe that. For me, committing to being a people pleaser is like committing to being a drug addict or a gambler – given enough time, the road ends in catastrophe.

Let’s talk about some of the costs, some that you’ll already know about and some that are coming up.

The main one internally is going to be an ever-growing resentment. You’re constantly suppressing your needs and desires. You’re constantly allowing people to mistreat you. You’re constantly upset that people do mistreat you and how that represents how terrible the world is. And this is just building, one percent at a time, over and over again after every incident. You develop this deep-seated rage that you try to suppress and try to pretend isn’t there.

It comes out every now and then and scares the shit out of you, because you’re just building up this unfairness victim identity about how you’re such a good person and you get punished for it and everybody else gets away with being a dick, and you’re just not getting the rewards you should for being the hero of the story. You’re not setting boundaries and expressing what you want and allowing that to upset people and sort out your social life, so now you’re surrounded with people who use you or ignore you or treat you like shit in other ways.

This resentment just keeps building. The sense of unfairness, this victim-like sense, gets worse every day because you don’t want to face yourself around this. You blame everyone else. You blame your childhood. You blame your parents. You blame the way the world is. Some of you get really worked up about politics. You’re just constantly pointing at everybody else. “You cause my pain. You, you, you, you. I’m doing everything right. You’re causing my pain.”

When really there’s only ever been one person causing your pain.

The cost socially is enormous, and it’s really hard to see because you’re getting lots of short-term rewards, or what appear to be rewards: positive reactions, approval, validation. You’re not seeing the long-term cost. You might think that you’re really fooling everybody because you’re fooling yourself. You might think the way you’re being is quite genuine, and that other people feel that way about you, and yet you’re also able to recognize when other people are people pleasers. In fact, it looks obvious as fuck to you, right? When someone’s being fake and falsely polite and trying to make everyone like them, it’s so obvious to you, and yet you think that you’re not obvious like that.

Fucking newsflash: You are just as obvious.

Just because people react well to you, just because you get positive reactions, doesn’t mean that they’re fooled by the act. I mean, we laugh at stand-up comedians, but we still know they’re trying to be funny. We’re not like, “Oh my God, that’s spontaneous!” right?

People know that you’re doing this. They might forgive you. They might enjoy being around you. They might even use you for it. But they do not trust you. They do not respect you. They cannot truly love you. They can become codependent if they’re also fucked up, but how could someone love you if they don’t know who you really are? And if you’re not being truthful, then they don’t know who you really are.

Whatever love you’re receiving is based on your act, not on who you actually are. They love your performance. It’s like someone pretending to be you and getting all the love. They might trust you in terms of they trust the performance – they know that you’re always going to be a nice guy or a people pleaser. They might think of you as reliable because you never say no to anything. But that doesn’t mean they trust you.

And you’ll notice this. You’ll often be disappointed and insulted by how people won’t trust you with certain things and how they’ll go to other people for help when they should have come to you. And you’ll be like, “Why? I’ve been such a solid player in your life. Why would you go to someone else? I’m insulted.” Well, it’s because they know that you’re not real. You can’t be trusted. When they need real shit, they have to go to a real person.

All of this erodes your self-respect. There is no people pleaser in the world who has self-respect. Those two things will never meet, because deep down, no matter what kind of lies you’ve told yourself and believed, you know you’re not being honest. You know you’re hiding your preferences. You know you’re pretending to agree. You know you’re exaggerating your stories. You know all this.

Now in the moment, you kind of reconcile it with yourself, justify it, explain it to yourself, minimize it. But the fact you have to do all that explaining and justifying – you wouldn’t have to do that with the truth. So you know you’re being dishonest, and dishonesty is a form of self-disrespect, in that respect is allowing what is to be. It is what it is. That is what respect is all about. You’re saying that your truth is not good enough, that you’re going to have to be something else.

Every time you’re dishonest, you’re basically saying to yourself, I’m not good enough as I am. You say that to yourself dozens of times per day, for decades. What kind of impact do you think that’s going to have?

Imagine if someone else was doing it to you. Every time you went to tell a story, they’re like, “No, no, you have to exaggerate it. You’re not funny enough.” Or you went to share an opinion and they interrupted with, “Shut up! Your opinion sucks. Keep it to yourself.” If someone else was doing that all day every day, you’d call that person abusive. You’d call them a bully. Yet that’s exactly what you’re doing to yourself.

Your integrity is being eroded. It’s probably a long time since you even knew what living with integrity was. You might have known it as a child, but that quickly got punished out of you. You know you’re just not living by your own principles. You try to justify it to yourself. That’s why you call yourself a good person. That’s why you think making people happy is a good thing. But deep down, you know you don’t respect your own behavior.

You lie awake at night resenting yourself for the things you’ve done or haven’t done – often for things you haven’t done, the opportunities you missed. “I wish I had just said something,” and so on.

I think most heartbreaking cost of all is the loneliness. You cannot actually connect with people when you’re a people pleaser. That was the key pain in my life. When I got to about 25 years old, I felt completely alone. I felt like a unit of one, like nobody knew who I really was. I had a couple of close friends and maybe I sort of dismissed that, but they were living their own lives. They weren’t around that often.

Nearly all of my interactions were forced, a bit fake. I was trying to be funny all the time. I wasn’t letting my true emotions show. I was trying to look tough and cool. And all that meant is I just didn’t feel like I was really with anyone. I knew they didn’t like me for who I was. It was almost like I was watching them have a relationship with someone else, this guy that I made up who’s getting all the credit and who’s better than me.

It was a very isolating feeling and it just kept getting worse and worse, especially as the few people who knew me well were moving on with their lives and I wasn’t seeing them as much. I started to forecast this trajectory. I realised this is only going to escalate. I was getting lonelier and lonelier as time passed, and that started to scare the shit out of me. I couldn’t see this getting any better. I knew that doing the same thing was going to keep me in the same results.

So just because people like you doesn’t mean it’s you that they like. It doesn’t mean you have a connection with them. You can have one hundred friends and still be all alone. I’ve been there.

Now the funny thing is, people pleasing doesn’t even work. I think if people pleasing at least pleased people, then I’d be out of business as a coach. If you at least constantly got rewarding reactions to it over time, then you probably could live with that forever. And there’s some people who do. I think of Hollywood actors and people who’ve taken performing and pleasing others to the highest possible degree. They’ve been rewarded so strongly for it that it doesn’t occur to them to try something else.

Now they’ll still be miserable later. I know this. Some of them are my clients. But they can keep doing it for a long time. Some clients come to me when they’re in their twenties and thirties because that’s how quickly it stopped working. But there are others who come to me in their fifties and sixties. It’s not that it was actually working that well, but they were in denial.

But that’s the thing. If people pleasing really did bring in the rewards as it’s supposed to, I think a lot of people would be okay with being fake. But it doesn’t even work for that. People won’t even like you that much because, if nothing else, people can feel the incongruence. We are all very sensitive to fakeness. That’s in our DNA. It’s a survival mechanism. The people who were not sensitive to that died out hundreds of years ago.

While a lot of people can be manipulated, they still usually know something’s off when it’s happening. They just don’t respect themselves. Very few people are manipulated without any sense of a red flag at any point in the process. It’s just they override that sense or they ignore it.

So if you think that you really are fooling people, that they go, “Wow, that is genuinely a good dude,” –  even if they say that – watch them carefully. How they respond to you, how well they trust you, where they prioritize you in their life. You’ll notice that not that many people are buying it.

There are some people out there, some people who you’ve missed such an opportunity with, who hate you because you’re a people pleaser. And if you’d only been real with them from the beginning, they might be your closest friend now, because they’re absolutely disgusted by inauthenticity. In my experience, in my professional opinion, the more confident a person is, the more disgusted they are by fakeness. So if you’re being inauthentic, you’re actually pushing away the best possible people. That’s not exactly a win!

If there are people out there who really love your people pleasing and they seem genuinely rewarded by it and they love it that you make them happy, those people are fucked up. You already know this. I don’t need to convince you of this. You’ve had those friends and partners who became codependent on you, who fall apart without you. You’re their therapist. You’re their comedian and entertainer. You’re their fucking handyman that fixes everything. You know they’re messed up. If anybody falls apart because you go away for a while, that person is unwell.

So the best case scenario for a long-term people pleaser is the only people who can stay in their life are even more fucked up than they are.

People can feel when niceness isn’t honest. They might say you’re a nice person. They might say that you’re lovely, but they notice that you have a very shallow emotional range. They notice that you don’t seem to react the way a healthy person would react. You don’t seem to be upset enough. You don’t seem to care about things enough.

Now there are some exceptions. There are some people pleasers who have wild mood swings, but generally the sense is this person is robotic. It’s like someone put AI into a human body and it’s trying to pretend to be a person. They get that sense from you, the flat affect sense, because they can feel that manipulation, especially when you try to convince them and you try to help them without their permission and you’re forcing yourself on them. They can feel that manipulation and it makes them defensive. It makes them feel unsafe.

One of my big breakthroughs in understanding why I was struggling so much with women is because while I could make them laugh and solve all their problems and it was really easy to be around me, there was something unsafe about me, something untrustworthy. I don’t think they could have even articulated it. They didn’t even know what it was. They just had this little inner warning system that said to them, “Enjoy yourself, sure, but don’t let this guy get too close.”

Over time, you start subconsciously sorting people. All the confident ones are pushed away. All the healthy people leave you, and you’re left with the ones who want you to please them. They want you to not be yourself. They benefit from you being this way. They’re codependent, and that’s if you’re lucky.

You might be with a partner who’s also working on themselves, and you can do this work at the same time, and you can both grow together. You don’t have to start healthy. You just both have to be moving in the same direction. But for a lot of you, you’ll be surrounded by enablers. Maybe you have parents that want you to be this way, friends, coworkers, and you now feel trapped. You’re surrounded by unhealthy people who want you to remain unhealthy.

Even if people can’t explain exactly why they don’t trust people pleasers, they don’t really want them in deep. That’s why you always feel like you’re on the outside of the group, trying to cling on, occasionally getting begrudgingly accepted for short periods of time. But ultimately, they know something’s off with you, and that’s why you’re not in the inner circle and never will be… if you keep behaving this way.

That thing that you’re doing to avoid them rejecting you and avoid being ostracized and trying to make them like you, the opposite is what ends up happening. You end up all alone. Avoiding all that rejection just leads to total rejection; a rejection of yourself by yourself, and a complete lack of trust and acceptance from others. The people pleasing strategy simply doesn’t work.

Honesty as The Alternative

I want you to open up to the idea that you can be honest and caring; that being kind to people doesn’t mean making them experience the emotion of happiness all the time; that sometimes the kindest, most caring thing you can do for someone is something that they will be upset by in the short term. And their various emotions that we call being upset, like being disappointed or frustrated or guilty or sad, these are things they need to feel to help them process the truth of life. You making them happy prevents them from processing these things. You’re not really helping them, you’re holding them back just so you feel more comfortable.

Being honest and caring allows disappointment. It allows people to go through the processing of difficult emotions. It respects other people’s autonomy. It lets them decide for themselves what the right thing to do is. It lets them make their own mistakes and it accepts the consequences.

It used to be I would do anything to prevent someone disliking me. I wouldn’t care if it ruined their life, so as long as they ended up liking me. I’ve done horrible things. I’ve talked people out of getting into relationships because I thought I might lose them as a friend. I’ve done all sorts of selfish, horrible things that I justified.

Nowadays, I would let someone hate me forever, for all the wrong reasons, so long as that’s what was best for them and their quality of life. I no longer am attached to them liking me. I’m more attached to people doing what’s best for them. And quite often that involves them being upset somewhere along the way. People pleasing avoids these kind of reactions. It’s always seeking approval and validation. It’s willing to sacrifice other people so that you can have another happy moment. How can you call yourself a good person with that motive?

Let’s check in here. I’m not going to tell you to stop people pleasing out of nowhere, because that’s not going to happen. You’ve got a lifetime of programming to overcome here. What I want you to do instead is something much smaller:

I want you to just NOTICE the next time you get that urge to make someone else happy.

Maybe it’s an anticipatory urge, like you start making them happy before you even see any other kind of emotion come up for them. You’re just automatically funny. You’re automatically adjusting your opinions before the conversation even starts.

Or maybe it’s reactive. You notice someone starts to get upset. You notice the little frown lines on their face, or you notice there’s a bit of conflict building between two people, and that urge you have to mediate it, to correct it, to change it.

Notice what that urge is telling you to do. Maybe it’s telling you to be funny, telling you to be interesting, telling you to agree when you actually don’t, telling you to change the subject. What is it doing to try and divert people back to ‘happiness’?

I want you to just have awareness of it. Just notice it, instead of it happening in this kind of blind, automatic, subconscious way. And once you’ve noticed it, just ask yourself a question.

What am I afraid is going to happen if I was honest instead?

People pleasing and honesty are not the same thing. You might be truthful when you’re people pleasing, but it’s carefully selected points truth. It’s not the real data that’s going to upset people.

When you notice that you get that urge to try and be funny, try to be cool, calm them down – ask yourself, “What do I actually wish I had the balls to say? What’s the truth going on inside that I’m not allowed to say right now?”

Just notice it. You don’t have to act on it. This isn’t a competition or a challenge. If nothing else, you’re just going to be honest with yourself about it so that you can see that this is not about the other person and their well-being. This is about you managing your fear. You’re not trying to make them happy. You’re trying to stop something bad happening to you.

If you can start seeing that and being truthful with yourself about that, you’re already ahead of ninety percent of people pleasers who are trying to work on this stuff. That’s most of the work, is just being honest with yourself about it.

If this pattern is something that’s ruining your life and you’re sick of it, you’re ready to do something about it, get in touch with me, dan@brojo.org, and we’ll start moving this thing along, but only when you’re ready.

Final Reflection

Let’s reflect on what we’ve talked about.

Let’s forgive your childhood self for coming up with a strategy. He or she was trying to keep you safe. It was something that was the most effective thing an immature mind could think of at the time, and it must have worked to some extent. It must have increased your quality of life, because otherwise you wouldn’t have kept doing it.

It was so effective at some time in the past, so it’s very hard to drop it. It’s the sunk cost fallacy. You’ve invested so much into being a people pleaser for so long, it feels like something you’ve got to maintain, something you’ve just got to tweak a little bit, keep most of it, maybe change a little bit, but you don’t want to throw away decades of hard work.

But before you can do anything about this, you must increase your awareness. You have to notice yourself doing this and be honest with yourself about what’s happening and why it’s happening.

You’ve got to let go of the idea that you’re this good person. It’s not a helpful identity. In fact, you’re more likely to be good if you can get to a more honest position anyway. If you really do want to be a good person, then stop lying to yourself. Start admitting to yourself what you’re doing and why you’re doing it.

You might feel like it’s overwhelming to make this change, but it’s not. Honesty is a spectrum. It’s a skill set. It’s not some personality trait that you either have or don’t have at any given time. The thing that comes out of your mouth or is expressed by your body could be a little bit more honest than usual, and you can just keep doing that for the rest of your life.

There’s no end to this. I’m still working on being more honest. I still slip every now and then, but honesty is the path out of this.

If you do want to exchange people pleasing for confidence, controlling people for actually caring for them, then honesty is the deal breaker for people pleasing. You can’t be a people pleaser and be completely honest at the same time. The two don’t go together.

So if you can ask yourself, “What’s a little bit more honesty look like?” Then you can see the path out of this thing.

But there will be consequences. There will be short-term upset, discomfort-type consequences. There’s no way around that. Honesty feels dangerous even when it’s the right thing to do. There are people who are not going to accept your honesty. Maybe many of them. You might be surrounded by people who need to live in a lie, and they’re going to react badly to someone opening things up to what’s real.

There are people out there who are going to react well to you being honest, though. Maybe you haven’t met them yet. Maybe you’ve spent your whole life repelling them. Might need to weed the garden before you can plant something new.

But this isn’t about other people. It’s about you and your fear. It’s about you deciding, “Am I going to be ruled by these childhood insecurities that no longer function and are causing my life to be miserable, or am I going to take a risk with another way of doing it that I’ve been convinced my whole life is risky?”

Let’s just see if that’s actually true, because we know people pleasing is hurting you. We don’t know for sure that honesty would.

I spent most of my life living this way simply because I didn’t know there was another option available. Once I started being honest, I realized I’d been missing out my whole life, that I’d been living a lie, and that being truthful was the only way to create a life that I wouldn’t regret in the long run.

A Serious Invitation to Coaching

If this post resonated with you, there’s a reason.

Most men who end up working with me aren’t looking for motivation, hacks, or surface-level confidence. They’re tired of circling the same problems with information overwhelm but not implementing successful changes.

They know what they should do. They’re just not consistently doing it.

Coaching is not for everyone. It’s not therapy, it’s not cheerleading, and it’s not about “fixing” you. 

It’s a structured, honest working relationship focused on behaviour change, taking responsibility for yourself, and improving the way you make decisions—especially the ones you keep avoiding.

This work is for you if:

  • You’re functional and capable, but something fundamental still isn’t working.
  • You’re done with intellectualizing your patterns and want them to actually change.
  • You’re willing to be challenged, not reassured.
  • You’re prepared to take responsibility for your choices instead of waiting to feel ready.

I’ve spent years making these mistakes myself and over a decade helping others stop repeating them. The difference coaching makes is not insight—it’s traction.

What working together looks like

  • Clear diagnosis of where you’re self-sabotaging (not just why)
  • Practical, uncomfortable actions that build real confidence
  • Direct feedback when you drift back into old patterns
  • A focus on integrity, not image or performance

If we work together, it will be because it makes sense—not because you were persuaded.

A no-pressure first session

I offer a free initial trial coaching session with no obligation to continue.

You can use it to see how I work, ask hard questions, and decide whether this is something you want to commit to.

If it’s not a fit, that’s fine. If it is, we’ll be clear about what comes next.

👉 Apply for an initial coaching session here

I only work with 8 clients at a time, and only with those prepared to take this seriously. I have 5 intro session spaces available each month – you may need to go onto a waitlist.

Dan Munro

If you’re looking for reassurance of your victim-story, this isn’t it. If you’re ready to change how you actually live, let’s stop messing around. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

JOIN BROJO TODAY

Confidence | Clarity | Connection

No more people-pleasing, Nice Guy Syndrome, or confidence issues.

The BROJO community will make sure you achieve your goals and build your self-worth with the support of members and coaches from all over the world.